Rich on the Plame-Outing Elephant

Frank Rich’s latest op-ed in the New York Times talks some more about the Plame-outing elephant I was ranting about the other day: Eight days in July. Among other great observations, he suggests that Alberto Gonzales’ failure to be nominated to the Supreme Court is a result of the scandal:

But the scandal has metastasized so much at this point that the forgotten man Mr. Bush did not nominate to the Supreme Court is as much a window into the White House’s panic and stonewalling as its haste to put forward the man he did. When the president decided not to replace Sandra Day O’Connor with a woman, why did he pick a white guy and not nominate the first Hispanic justice, his friend Alberto Gonzales? Mr. Bush was surely not scared off by Gonzales critics on the right (who find him soft on abortion) or left (who find him soft on the Geneva Conventions). It’s Mr. Gonzales’s proximity to this scandal that inspires real fear.

As White House counsel, he was the one first notified that the Justice Department, at the request of the C.I.A., had opened an investigation into the outing of Joseph Wilson’s wife. That notification came at 8:30 p.m. on Sept. 29, 2003, but it took Mr. Gonzales 12 more hours to inform the White House staff that it must “preserve all materials” relevant to the investigation. This 12-hour delay, he has said, was sanctioned by the Justice Department, but since the department was then run by John Ashcroft, a Bush loyalist who refused to recuse himself from the Plame case, inquiring Senate Democrats would examine this 12-hour delay as closely as an 18½-minute tape gap. “Every good prosecutor knows that any delay could give a culprit time to destroy the evidence,” said Senator Charles Schumer, correctly, back when the missing 12 hours was first revealed almost two years ago. A new Gonzales confirmation process now would have quickly devolved into a neo-Watergate hearing. Mr. Gonzales was in the thick of the Plame investigation, all told, for 16 months.

Thus is Mr. Gonzales’s Supreme Court aspiration the first White House casualty of this affair. It won’t be the last.

Good followup, including links to video from the weekend talking-heads shows, at TalkLeft: Alberto Gonzales told Card immediately about preservation order.

One Response to “Rich on the Plame-Outing Elephant”

  1. adam_blust Says:

    Great insight by Rich on the possible reason why GWB didn’t nominate his friend Gonzales. I saw Gonzales on one of the Sunday shows and he looked absolutely ashen. I have a great curiousity about what’s going on behind closed doors at the White House these days.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.